If it is good and right that we should reflect God's character—his love, compassion, mercy, grace, and so on—would it not also be good and right that we should reflect his judgment and justice? If so, how? Do we act as judge or do we work at discernment? Do we seek to bring wrongdoers to justice, or do we care for the victims—or both?
Consider 1 Cor 2:15: "Those who are spiritual can evaluate all things, but they themselves cannot be evaluated by others."